Collapsed Trachea/Collar questions
+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 20

Thread: Collapsed Trachea/Collar questions

  1. #1
    Stazz's Avatar
    Stazz is offline Village Admiral
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    Durban, South Africa
    Posts
    3,009

    Default Collapsed Trachea/Collar questions

    Hello PV !!!

    We had a dog behaviourst come in, just to show us some things...its was really fascinating. She did mention Yoda (6 months) needs some serious leadership when it comes to walking on his leash...so she put a material choke collar on his leash, and said we must train him this way....only until he gets the hang of walking next to us and not running amock on his harness. So, my question is....I thought her being a Pro, it would be okay...but I downloaded this Pug Book, and it says we must NOT use a collar on a pug, of any age, ever, as it can cause a collapsed trachea! So yeah - not too sure what to do?!

  2. #2
    snort's Avatar
    snort is offline Village Admiral
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    Kelowna,B.C.Canada
    Posts
    3,179

    Default

    I never use collars on my pugs for that reason, I dont want to do anything to injure or damage them. That being said, I use harnesses on them both and they pull like little sled dogs! although I havent really tried much to break them of it Im sure someone will chime in with some training advice without having to use a collar on them.

  3. #3
    andy9020's Avatar
    andy9020 is offline Village Mayor
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Nine Mile Falls, Washington
    Posts
    387

    Default

    When we walk our pugs we never attach the lead to theit collars. we use the Puppia harnesses on them because they gor over the chest of the pugs. when we walk and they try to pull we get them to stop pulling using a commanding "NO PULL". We never shout at them, but we use that to remind them who the alpha is in the group. They generally mind pretty well. Best of luck with training!
    http://www.meetup.com/SpokanePugGroup/ Organizer

    Married to: Lindsey
    Owned By: Murphy, Jack and Lillie

  4. #4
    Lindsey's Avatar
    Lindsey is offline Village Admiral
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    Eastern Washington State (The Lilac City)
    Posts
    2,763

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by andy9020 View Post
    When we walk our pugs we never attach the lead to theit collars. we use the Puppia harnesses on them because they gor over the chest of the pugs. when we walk and they try to pull we get them to stop pulling using a commanding "NO PULL". We never shout at them, but we use that to remind them who the alpha is in the group. They generally mind pretty well. Best of luck with training!
    I agree with Hubby above.

    Oh My! Well this specialist doesn't seem to be a pug specialist. I would never attach a leash to my pugs collars. It just is not a good idea. All three of ours wear collars, but they are very loose (they can slip them off if they wanted too). When we walk them or they are out in public they always have a harness on them.
    I would assume you can train Yoda wearing a harness. I'm sure many PV'ers have done it.
    Lindsey
    owned by pugs; Murphy, Jack & Lillie
    Wife to Andy (Andy9020)




  5. #5
    Rosiepug's Avatar
    Rosiepug is offline Moderator et Village Parisienne
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Oooh lala, je suis a PARIS, fr
    Posts
    8,703

    Default

    I would never use a collar on a pug or a choke collar on any other dog........ it's the easy way out which equals you pull, I choke you!

    Whether using an ordinary collar or a harness, commanding and luring, offering rewards is the only way to go in my opinion.

    When in harness put Yoda by your left side, leash in your right hand and give a command i.e. Yoda heel, and set off walking, don't look at him, look straight ahead and walk with a purpose. As soon as he starts to pull, STOP dead in your tracks, when he relaxes and the leash slackens (and this may take a few minutes) put him in place again commanding Yoda heel, you can lure him with a treat in your left hand when he does a few steps correctly. Continue to command heel, always using his name before a command and treat very frequently for correct behavor. As time goes by he'll do more for less rewards but in the beginning he'll need plenty of treats and verbal rewards.

    This takes time, you won't fix it overnight but if you can do 2 x 10 minutes a day, followed by a play session like fetch, he'll get to understand what you're asking and will see it as fun, he gets rewards and he gets playtime afterwards. Gradually lengthen the training sessions as he concentrates for longer.

    ETA, I just read in your other thread that your puppy is only six months old. Please don't use a choke collar on him, he has soft bones, ligament and tissues and is still growing. No telling what damage it could do but imagine the worst case scenario.
    Last edited by Rosiepug; 03-01-2010 at 02:00 AM. Reason: add on
    www.parischiennepugs.com

    ]acqueline et
    Les Parischiennes,
    L'Impératrice Rosephine de Bonaparte
    La Marquise Halcyone de Pompadour

    PUDDING @ 9 wks
    CRUFTS QUALIFIED 2010


    Mademoiselle Amaryllis qui m'attende au pont d'arc 27.3.99-14.11.06

  6. #6
    Stazz's Avatar
    Stazz is offline Village Admiral
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    Durban, South Africa
    Posts
    3,009

    Default

    GOODNESS ME ! Thank you all for your input - I will NOT ever use the collar again, I've only used it a couple times, have always hated the choke collar. I feel like a bad mommy. But I am so happy I know what you all say and think, and I will rather go with pugxperts than the behaiviourist. I realize how serious this is and will only use the harness form now on. Rosiepug, I really appreciate your training advice - I'm going to try that from now on. He is still a "baby" and would NEVER want anything to happen to him, rather him be safe and happy at all times :)

    I JUST LOVE THIS `FORUM !

  7. #7
    Snifter's Avatar
    Snifter is offline Moderator/Village Merchant
    Join Date
    Dec 2005
    Location
    Essex, England
    Posts
    15,402

    Default

    Absolutely do not use a choke collar.

    For shows etc my dogs have to wear a collar. I have used half check (martingale) collars on mine. These tighten but only to a pre-set amount so they don't choke the dog but it lessens the risk of them slipping off.

    If you have a really hard puller a collar could well cause damage, though. The collars for the show ring are very narrow, but for practising I use a fairly wide half check collar so that if there is a bit of an unexpected pull the strain is at least spread over a wider area.


    Bella, mummy to Snifter and Toddy!

    http://avrilmunson.wordpress.com









  8. #8
    jwestoverpug's Avatar
    jwestoverpug is offline Village Royalty
    Join Date
    Apr 2003
    Location
    Regent Square, PA
    Posts
    4,262

    Default

    Just about anyone can claim to be a "pro", but it doesn't mean anything! There are wonderful dog trainers out there, unfortunately this one sounds stuck about 20 yrs behind the times! Dogs don't pull because they they need leadership, they pull because they want to walk faster and haven't been taught pulling won't work.

    I have no problem using a reg. collar or martingale, but never ever a choke, and the whole point is to keep the leash slack, so they never feel any tension on the collar. If a dog was seriously pulling and choking themselves I would use a harness that you clip the leash to the front (there are special harnesses made this way, but any harness with an O ring on the front can be used this way.)
    Jesse and the pugs
    Rudy "Stop These Feet from Dancin NA OAJ"
    Willy "Bishop's Willy the Kid NA OAJ"
    Kittie "CH MACH CandyLand's Sugar Babie NAP NJP OAP AJP CGC"
    Abby "Pennwood's Rising Star AX AXJ NAP NJP CGC"
    Indy, "Pasun's Trip To The Moon OA NAJ" papillon in training

  9. #9
    shaynapug's Avatar
    shaynapug is offline Village Royalty
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    Berkley, MI
    Posts
    30,967

    Default

    The only dog I ever used a thin choke collare with was Nikki. I needed it cuz she paced and I had to get her out of it. But....it was slack 99.9 of the time!

    I use show leads to show my guys......

    Have collars to walk them, but prefer the harnesses.
    Diane
    Shayna Pugs
    http://www.midmichiganpugclub.com
    Chairperson of PDCA Rescue Committee

  10. #10
    ownedby5pugs is offline Village Mayor
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    WA State
    Posts
    105

    Default

    No collars on my crew either. My oldest is 12 and younger one is 9 and they have never worn collars. It's not worth the risk in my eyes.

    Marie

+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts